Achieving WCAG Compliance: A Practical Checklist for Online Help Documentation

Ensuring WCAG compliance in online help documentation is crucial for inclusive digital experiences as well as avoiding legal ramifications. Organizations committed to inclusive communication understand that help documentation serves as a critical touchpoint for users —  but large organizations often struggle with the complex landscape of web accessibility and digital accessibility. This leads to significant challenges in creating technical documentation that meets the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) while catering to the user experience.

This article provides essential guidance for creating accessible online help documentation. Below you'll find actionable strategies and considerations to systematically address key accessibility requirements, ensuring your documentation effectively serves all users, including those relying on assistive technologies. To support your implementation, we’ve included a simple WCAG compliance checklist and tips for checking to ensure your documentation is WCAG compliant.

What is WCAG Compliance?

The Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) 2.1 or 2.2, developed by the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C), represent a comprehensive framework designed to ensure digital content is accessible to individuals with diverse abilities. This framework is structured around four core principles, known as POUR: Perceivable, Operable, Understandable, and Robust. These principles provide a standardized approach to web accessibility, ensuring that all digital content can be perceived, understood, and navigated by all users.

Here’s a breakdown of the POUR principles:

• Perceivable: Digital content must be presented in ways users can perceive, regardless of sensory limitations. This means providing text alternatives for visual elements, audio descriptions for time-based media, and ensuring adaptability to various sensory needs like visual, auditory, and tactile access.
• Operable: User interface components and navigation must be operable by all users, including those who use assistive technologies, supporting keyboard focus, voice commands, and alternative input modalities. The goal is to enable all users to easily use interactive features and complete tasks, regardless of their input method.
• Understandable: Content and user interface operations must be comprehensible. This involves using clear, concise language, maintaining predictable functionality and consistent design to reduce cognitive disabilities impact, and presenting information logically, aiding screen reader users and those with cognitive or learning disabilities.
• Robust: Content must be compatible with current and future user agents. This includes assistive technologies, following standard web development practices to ensure broad interpretation, and ensuring that when functionality occurs it’s compatible across multiple platforms.

Adhering to standard web development practices that support broad interpretation and interaction capabilities is crucial for technical implementations aiming to meet the following WCAG conformance levels.

There are three conformance levels—A, AA, and AAA:

• Level A: Represents the most basic web accessibility requirements. These are the minimum standards that must be met to provide fundamental accessibility.
• Level AA: Provides a more comprehensive standard of accessibility, recommended for most organizations seeking inclusive digital content.
• Level AAA: Offers the most extensive accessibility requirements, which can be challenging to implement completely across all content types.

Each WCAG conformance level progressively addresses the POUR principles, with Level A covering basic needs, Level AA offering a more comprehensive approach, and Level AAA targeting the highest accessibility standards. However, while Level AAA offers the highest level of accessibility, achieving Level AA conformance is generally considered the most practical and widely accepted industry standard for accessible web content.

Challenges and Risks of Non-Compliance

Large organizations face significant hurdles when implementing web accessibility standards across their documentation ecosystems. The complexity of maintaining comprehensive WCAG compliance requires strategic approaches and dedicated resources.

Specific Challenges in WCAG Compliance

The challenges large organizations encounter when striving for WCAG compliance across their documentation include:

• Consistency across documents: Maintaining uniform WCAG applications across vast documentation libraries presents a significant challenge. Inconsistent application of WCAG guidelines can create substantial barriers users face, requiring robust content governance strategies and continuous monitoring. Developing a centralized approach to documentation accessibility becomes critical for large, complex organizations.
• Accessibility during updates: Preserving accessibility during frequent content revisions and updates is essential. Each revision presents a potential risk of introducing accessibility barriers that can compromise the user experience for individuals with disabilities. Organizations must develop robust version control processes that integrate accessibility compliance checks into every content update.
• Team training: Providing ongoing, comprehensive WCAG guidelines training to large teams is crucial for fostering a culture of inclusive design. These training initiatives should focus not just on technical checklist items, but on cultivating empathy and understanding of diverse user needs. Continuous learning and periodic refresher courses become essential to maintain a high level of accessibility awareness across the entire documentation team.

Addressing these challenges requires a strategic, organization-wide commitment to accessibility.

Risks of Non-Compliance

Organizations that fail to prioritize web accessibility expose themselves to significant potential consequences. Understanding these risks is crucial for motivating comprehensive WCAG compliance efforts:

• Legal and Financial Risks: Facing financial penalties and reputational damage from legal challenges due to accessibility violations under digital accessibility laws. These legal actions can stem from violations of the Americans with Disabilities Act and other regional accessibility legislation. The financial and reputational costs of defending against accessibility-related lawsuits can far exceed the investment required to implement proper WCAG compliance.
• Brand Reputation Damage: Experiencing negative impacts on brand reputation due to perceived lack of commitment to digital accessibility. Potential customers and stakeholders increasingly evaluate companies based on their dedication to accessibility and equal access to information. A reputation for exclusionary practices can lead to significant erosion of customer trust and potential loss of business opportunities.
• User Exclusion: Excluding users with cognitive or learning disabilities, screen reader users, and those who use mobile devices, contradicting ethical principles of digital inclusivity. Non-compliant documentation creates substantial barriers users face, preventing individuals with diverse abilities from accessing critical information. By neglecting accessibility, organizations not only fail to serve a significant portion of their potential user base but also limit their reach within the market.

Therefore, proactive WCAG compliance is not only an ethical imperative but also a crucial business strategy.

WCAG Compliance Checklist for Online Help Documentation

To ensure your online help documentation is accessible to all users, follow this practical checklist based on the POUR principles:

Is it Perceivable?

To make your help documentation perceivable, ensure that all users can access and understand the content, regardless of their sensory abilities. This includes providing alternative text for images, captions for videos, ensuring content can be presented in different ways, and ensuring sufficient color contrast.

• Add meaningful alt text: For all images and non-text elements, provide concise, descriptive alternative text.
• Include captions and transcripts: Ensure all multimedia content has synchronized captions and transcripts.
• Make content adaptable: Design content to adapt to different screen sizes and assistive technologies.
• Ensure sufficient color contrast: Verify that text and interactive elements have sufficient color contrast against their backgrounds.
• Use semantic markup: Employ structured markup, specifically DITA, to define content elements semantically, enhancing adaptability for assistive technologies.

Is it Operable?

Operability focuses on making your help documentation navigable and interactive for all users, including those who rely on keyboard navigation or assistive technologies. This includes ensuring all interactive elements are accessible, providing sufficient time for users to interact with content, and providing clear focus indicators.

• Enable keyboard navigation: Ensure all interactive elements are fully navigable using a keyboard.
• Set clear time limits: Provide sufficient time for users to interact with content, and include options to adjust or extend time limits.
• Create consistent navigation: Implement clear and consistent navigation structures throughout the documentation.
• Provide clear focus indicators: Ensure interactive elements have visible focus indicators when navigated with a keyboard.

Is it Understandable?

To make your help documentation understandable, focus on using clear language, consistent formatting, and providing helpful error handling. This ensures that users can easily comprehend the content and avoid confusion.

• Use plain language: Write content using clear, concise language, avoiding jargon and complex sentence structures.
• Maintain consistent formatting: Use consistent terminology and formatting throughout the documentation. Structured content is essential for achieving this.
• Provide clear and informative error messages: Implement error prevention mechanisms and provide clear, informative error messages that explain the error and suggest solutions.

Is it Robust?

Robust help documentation is compatible with a wide range of user agents and assistive technologies. This requires validating your code and regularly testing your documentation with different tools.

• Ensure assistive technology compatibility: Verify that the documentation works seamlessly with various assistive technologies.
• Validate code: Validate HTML and CSS to ensure they meet accessibility standards and are free of errors.
• Test with assistive technologies: Regularly test the documentation using different assistive technologies.
• Ensure accessible content reuse: When reusing content components, verify that accessibility features and information (e.g., alt text) are preserved.
• Validate output formats: Ensure the accessibility of all output formats generated from the source content, including HTML, PDF, and other formats.

Implementing these steps will help you achieve a significant level of WCAG compliance, ensuring that your online help documentation is accessible to all users, providing a better user experience and increasing overall satisfaction. Use this checklist as a starting point, and regularly review and update your documentation to ensure ongoing accessibility and maintain compliance with the latest WCAG standards.

Checking for WCAG Compliance

Ensuring ongoing WCAG compliance requires organizations to implement a comprehensive approach to verifying and continually improving their web accessibility standards. 

To effectively check for WCAG compliance, organizations should employ the following methods:

• Using automated accessibility testing tools: Use specialized software to quickly identify potential accessibility issues, providing initial insights and streamlining compliance verification. Automated testing serves as an essential first step in identifying and addressing accessibility barriers.
• Conducting manual accessibility audits: Supplement automated testing with expert manual reviews to identify nuanced issues and provide a holistic assessment of documentation accessibility. Manual audits allow for in-depth analysis of user experience and interaction challenges.
• Involving users with disabilities in testing: Engage users with diverse abilities in testing to gain real-world insights and ensure accessibility improvements are based on actual user needs. This user-centered approach provides invaluable feedback on the practical accessibility of the documentation.

‍

Create More Inclusive Documentation with Heretto

Achieving WCAG compliance for online help documentation is a multifaceted process that demands strategic planning, ongoing education, and a genuine commitment to inclusivity. By systematically addressing the POUR principles and implementing a comprehensive accessibility strategy, organizations can create documentation that serves all users effectively.

Heretto can streamline this process, providing the tools and features necessary to create and maintain accessible documentation. Heretto's component content management system (CCMS) facilitates the creation of modular content that can be easily adapted to various formats and devices, a key aspect of WCAG's "perceivable" principle. Additionally, Heretto's user-friendly workflow features can integrate accessibility checks into the content creation process, ensuring ongoing compliance.

The journey to full accessibility is continuous. Take the first step by implementing this checklist, and then commit to regularly assessing and updating your documentation to remove barriers for users with diverse abilities. With Heretto, you can make this ongoing process more efficient and effective. Schedule your free demo today.

‍